| Player | Points |
| Matthew Dogan, West Middlesex vs. Wilmington | 45 |
| Jaymon Mason, General McLane vs. McDowell | 43 |
| Matthew Dogan, West Middlesex vs. Rocky Grove | 42 |
| Jaymon Mason, General McLane vs. Strong Vincent | 42 |
| Kyle McKeen, Northwestern vs. Mercyhurst Prep | 40 |
| Khalil Hopson, Sharon vs. George Junior | 39 |
| Zak Price, Meadville vs. Seneca | 37 |
| Jaymon Mason, General McLane vs. Strong Vincent | 37 |
| Jaymon Mason, General McLane vs. Warren | 37 |
| Khalil Hopson, Sharon vs. Grove City | 36 |
| Nafis Brown, George Junior vs. Meadville | 34 |
| Matthew Dogan, West Middlesex vs. Sharpsville | 34 |
| Matt Votino, Hickory vs. Sharon | 34 |
| Jaymon Mason, General McLane vs. East | 34 |
| Sheldon Zablotny, Cathedral Prep vs. Central Tech | 33 |
| Nafis Brown, George Junior vs. Grove City | 33 |
| Donte Hollingsworth, Meadville vs. East | 33 |
| Demetrius McClennan, VisionQuest vs. Jamestown | 33 |
| Aaron Lundmark, Eisenhower vs. Maplewood | 33 |
| Taylor Lenzi, Sharpsville vs. Jamestown | 32 |
| Logan Way, Oil City vs. Cranberry | 32 |
| Logan Way, Oil City vs. George Junior | 32 |
| Jason Page, Farrell vs. Meadville | 32 |
| Eugene Husband, Central Tech vs. Cathedral Prep | 32 |
| Eugene Husband, Central Tech vs. Strong Vincent | 32 |
| Tyler Luchey, Sharpsville vs. Lakeview | 31 |
| Noah Uplinger, Conneaut vs. Cambridge Springs | 31 |
| Nafis Brown, George Junior vs. Franklin | 31 |
| Matthew Dogan, West Middlesex vs. Sharpsville | 31 |
| Logan Clarke, Mercer vs. Reynolds | 31 |
| Jordan Smith, Wilmington vs. Shenango | 31 |
| Jeremy Jancso, West Middlesex vs. Beaver | 31 |
| Derek Turner, Grove City vs. George Junior | 31 |
| Demetrius McClennan, VisionQuest vs. Hickory | 31 |
| Sheldon Zablotny, Cathedral Prep vs. McDowell | 30 |
| Noah Uplinger, Conneaut vs. Fort LeBoeuf | 30 |
| Noah Uplinger, Conneaut vs. Eisenhower | 30 |
| Nafis Brown, George Junior vs. Oil City | 30 |
| Michael Beck, McDowell vs. Central Tech | 30 |
| Matthew Dogan, West Middlesex vs. Reynolds | 30 |
| Logan Way, Oil City vs. Grove City | 30 |
| Jaymon Mason, General McLane vs. Harbor Creek | 30 |
| Jaymon Mason, General McLane vs. Harbor Creek | 30 |
| Izeem Hunter, VisionQuest vs. Rocky Grove | 30 |
| Eugene Husband, Central Tech vs. George Junior | 30 |
| Aaron Lundmark, Eisenhower vs. Cambridge Springs | 30 |
–Tom Reisenweber
